Michael DeSafey | Executive Recruiter and HR Professional

Red Flags for Bad Hires! Nine Key Signs You’ve Hired the Wrong Person

Factors that Indicate the Person You Just Hired Was a Bad Move

Red Flags for Bad Hires! Nine Key Signs You've Hired the Wrong Person.

Date : April 17, 2023 | By : michael_desafey

If you’re regularly interviewing job candidates, there’s no way around it: from time to time, you’ll make a bad hiring decision. Sometimes, it’s not until after they’ve been on the job for a while that you realize they’re not a good fit for the position. If you observe the following red flags, it may be time to start reflecting on whether they deserve another chance, or whether it’s time to let them go.

Bad Attitude

A bad attitude is one of the most significant red flags when it comes to evaluating your employees. No matter how seasoned, skilled, or stable the candidate might seem, someone with a bad attitude will not be able to hold their own in the workplace.

Poor Organization

A poorly organized employee will not be able to keep up with the work required. If they don’t maintain a current list of their files, for example, they might not even know if they have the correct files on hand. This will affect their work performance (as well as reflect poorly on your hiring skills). File organizing is even more important in engineering and IT because these fields rely on an up-to-date and functional file system. Bad organization on the part of an employee can lead to countless problems, so it’s vital to hire someone who can stay organized.

Punctuality

One of the essential attributes of any potential employee is their availability during working hours. Consider a candidate who looked good on paper, but can’t meet one of the most basic expectations laid out in their employment contract, namely showing up on time in the morning. Employees like these are clearly showing you that they don’t understand the requirements of the job or ignoring them; if you keep them on, you have nobody but yourself to blame.

Dismissed Feedback

Any employee who’s interested in improving their job performance will value good feedback. If a candidate refuses to accept feedback, that’s another sign that they may not be the best hire for you. This is particularly relevant when the feedback you provide is backed up by observations of their workplace behavior.

Inconsistent Communication

If a job candidate is constantly missing deadlines for submitting reports or making contact with you, this may leave you wondering whether they’re up to the task of being your employee. A number of factors can cause these inconsistencies, but it’s important to note that someone who’s easily distracted (and will therefore be likely to miss deadlines) may not be the best person for the role. Construction work, graphic design, and many other jobs require ultra-dedicated workers, so consistency is a must.

Numerous Mistakes

One critical aspect of any job is ensuring that your employees are doing what they’re supposed to do. If an employee has mistakenly performed tasks outside their job description, this can be a huge indicator that you’re about to have a bad time in the workplace. An employee who’s consistently underinformed or confused will cause problems that take valuable time and resources to fix—it’s always better to hire someone who is willing and able to do their job correctly.

Compromising Quality

If an employee lacks the ability to work to the standards your business requires, you will again be forced to put in more valuable time and effort to fix their mistakes. If you’re lucky enough to realize this early on, firing them before they do too much damage is the best option.

Lack of Commitment

This is another huge red flag. If an applicant doesn’t seem fully committed to the job you’re offering them, they may be a bad hire. Someone who struggles to stay interested in your company or position is unlikely to be a good employee. Working in an environmental field requires commitment, so if someone cannot commit to the job, be aware that they may not be a good fit.

Signs of Losing Interest

If a job candidate starts showing signs that they’re losing interest in the role, this may be a serious indication that they’ve already decided that your company is not for them. A bored employee can cause significant problems in the workplace. If an employee is struggling to get excited about their job, there may be negative consequences for your business.

Michael DeSafey is a leading executive recruiter for professionals in the construction, engineering, and environmental industries. He is currently the President of Webuild Staffing: www.webuildstaffing.com. To learn more about Michael, or to follow his blog, please visit www.michaeldesafey.com.